|Healthcare Training Institute - Quality Education since 1979CE for Psychologist, Social Worker, Counselor, & MFT!!
The Freak Lightning Bolt - Helping Clients find their 'Percent of Responsibility'
Read content below or listen to audio.
Left click audio track to Listen; Right click to "Save..." mp3
In the last section, we discussed challenges in helping clients recall their emotions
during their trauma: resistant clients, risks, and unresolved
grief and anger.
Commonly, after a client has experienced severe trauma,
he or she has also experienced several losses. However, because the
common conception of grief is mourning for losses of life, many clients never
truly complete the grieving process.
In this section, we will examine
the three levels of grieving losses which include: grieving specific
losses, grieving the realization of powerlessness, and grieving mortality. We will address PTSD resulting from natural disasters.
3 Levels of Grieving Losses
♦ #1 Grieving Specific Losses
The first level, grief over specific losses, is the most well-known type of
grief, one in which people, objects, or physical, emotional, or spiritual
losses are defined and grieved for.
To help my clients recognize these
specific losses, I give them four categories to consider when identifying
- Financial Losses. Obviously, money, though not
as important as other losses, can be a great blow to anyone who has experienced
economic troubles. I tell my clients that there are two types of financial
losses: direct and indirect. Direct refers to those items that
had a price sticker at one time such as: cars, medical bills,
legal fees, damaged property and so on. Indirect losses refer to
the cost of lost opportunities such as career opportunities that were out
of bounds due to physical or psychological wounds.
- Emotional Losses. These include emotional symptoms
that the clients have suffered such as: anger, fear, and anxiety. It
can also refer to limitations resulting from trauma such as: social,
vocational, and other aspects of their life. I also ask my clients
to consider how the trauma affected his or her family and include that
in their emotional losses.
- Medical and Physical Losses. Obviously, these include
any injuries and handicaps, either physical or mental, resulting from the
trauma. I also ask my clients to list how these losses have affected
their lives such as their job, relationships, sex life, creative pursuits,
- Philosophical, Spiritual, and/or Moral Losses. Many
times, traumatic events spark skepticism in people about the kindness of
humanity or the existence and benevolence of God. I ask my clients
to list the many groups, organizations, religions, or beliefs that they
have since ceased believing or have at least begun to doubt as a result
of their traumatic experience.
By dividing losses into these four categories, clients have a much easier
time naming their losses and thus a much easier grieving process.
♦ #2 Grieving the Realization of Powerlessness
The second level of grieving, grieving the realization of powerlessness, involves
the client realizing that what they have lost maybe gone forever and will never
be regained. This takes a great action of the will from the client to
admit that they have no control over what’s happened to them.
survivors of natural disasters struggle with this due to their hesitancy to
accept the severe feelings of helplessness that overwhelmed them during the
Caleb was nine years old when his mother and father died
in a fire from a freak lightning bolt. Even though Caleb was relatively
young at the time of the incident, he still acutely felt the feelings of helplessness.
that moment on, Caleb suffered from highly developed survivor’s guilt,
stemming from the belief that if he had been present, he might have woken up
his parents and saved them. As we discussed in section 6, survivor guilt
results from the refusal to accept powerlessness as a fact of life. Now,
at 16, Caleb still feels responsible somehow for the death of his parents.
♦ Technique: Percentage of Responsibility
To help Caleb accept his powerlessness in the situation, I found the "Percentage
of Responsibility" technique helpful.
I asked Caleb to
answer and complete the following questions and commands that I put to him
- Verbalize the details of the event in the first person.
- What percentage of the event are you responsible for? Are you sure? Is
it possible that the percentage is more than that; or less?
- Who else shared responsibility? Others at the scene, people distant
from the scene? Societal influences?
- Recalculate responsibility so that the total is 100 percent, and accurately
focus on what you did and did not do.
- Describe how much you have suffered for the responsibility you have assigned
Caleb stated, "The lightning struck our house, and caught the roof
on fire first. I wasn’t there, but I saw it afterwards and I saw
the fire alarm that hadn’t gone off that could have saved my parents.
I guess I give myself about 35 percent responsibility." I asked
him, "Did you cause the storm?" Caleb responded that, no,
he hadn’t. I then asked him, "Oh, then you destroyed the
fire alarm that didn’t go off?"
He responded, "No,
I didn’t!" I said, "Well, then was it your responsibility
to change the batteries?" Caleb said, "No, I couldn’t
even reach that high." Then I asked him, "Did you know in
advance that the lightning was going to choose your house
on the same night that you spent the night at your friend’s house?" Caleb
stated, "No." I then asked him, "How much percentage
do you give yourself now?"
Caleb recalculated, "I guess
I give myself…5 percent." I asked him, "Why five percent
Caleb?" He responded "Because if I had been there, I could
have woken them up." I stated, "Caleb, do you really think
that you would have woken up at all yourself?" He said, "No,
I guess not." I then asked him to recalculate again his percentage
of responsibility which he now calculated as zero percent. As you can
see, Caleb had finally realized and accepted his powerlessness in stopping
♦ #3 Grieving Own Mortality
In addition to grieving for personal losses and grieving for a realization
of powerlessness, the third level of loss involves the client grieving their
own mortality. Obviously, the idea that one day they
are going to die is a client’s ultimate expression of powerlessness. In
Caleb’s case, at the same time that he was grieving the loss of his
parents, he was grieving the fact that someday he too will die. Therefore,
while Caleb undergoes the five stages of grief for his parents, simultaneously,
he will also be grieving his own mortality.
In this section, we discussed the three levels of grieving
losses which include: grieving
specific losses, grieving the realization of powerlessness, and grieving
In the next section, we will examine exercises to help
clients gain a feeling of empowerment: Taking Inventory, Refinding
Yourself, and Accentuating the Positive.
What are the three levels of grieving losses?
To select and enter your answer go to .
What are the
five steps in the "Percentage of Responsibility" Technique? To select and enter your answer go to .