Healthcare Training Institute - Quality Education since 1979
CE for Psychologist, Social Worker, Counselor, & MFT!!
Children with Asperger Syndrome (AS) have difficulty attending to social cues and experience problems in interpreting such stimuli. In addition, they have difficulty in (a) understanding the beliefs of others, (b) shifting attention, (c) sharing attention with others, and (d) distinguishing relevant from irrelevant stimuli. The relevance of attending to and understanding social cues is imperative because an understanding of the world most often comes from others' verbal cues, gestures, facial expressions, and so forth (Attwood, 1998; Myles & Simpson, 1998).
Gray (1995a, 1995b) developed two visual systems-social stories and comic strip conversations--that are designed to illustrate and interpret social situations and provide support to "students who struggle to comprehend the quick exchange of information which occurs in a conversation" (p. 2). These techniques turn an abstract situation into a concrete representation that allows for reflection. Social stories use a brief narrative that describes a situation, relevant social cues, and responses. Comic strip conversations promote social understanding by incorporating simple figures and other symbols in a comic strip format. An educator can draw or assist a student who illustrates a social situation in order to facilitate understanding.
Limited research exists on social stories. In fact, only four studies have been published on the effectiveness of this technique (Hagiwara & Myles, 1999; Kuttler, Myles, & Carlson, 1998; Norris & Datillo, 1999; Swaggart et al., 1995). Although the use of comic strip conversations has been reported anecdotally, to date no research has been published demonstrating the impact of this technique. The purpose of this article is to overview the use of social stories and comic strip conversations with a young man with AS.
Tom: An Adolescent with AS
Tom saw himself as having many friends across both general and special education settings, many of whom he considered to be best friends. Even though the majority of his general "friends" did not know his name or interact with him, Tom still felt he was an integral part of their social group. He did, however, interact with several students with special needs, although these interactions were not always pleasant. He had voiced distress over the "spats, bad words, and hurt feelings" that surrounded his relationships with these students.
Although Tom exhibited some degree of behavioral problems throughout the day, resource room teachers reported that his behavior appeared to escalate immediately following lunch and was maintained during physical education (PE), his first class after lunch. They described his behavior as confused. After lunch he would walk to his locker making facial grimaces, flapping his hands, and talking to himself. When he reached his locker, he would pace back and forth in front of it. The teachers reported that he needed several verbal or physical prompts to open his locker or gather materials for PE. Even with these prompts, Tom was often late to class, and his PE teacher noted that he appeared "agitated and unable to focus."
Social Stories and Comic Strip Conversations
After five individual meetings, a social story was introduced to Tom that outlined what occurred during lunch and the steps he was to follow to get from lunch to PE class. Tom read this story daily before lunch for 5 days. On the 10th day, the resource room teacher revised the social story to elaborate on some of the lunch activities and his movement from one activity to the next. Table 1 contains the two social stories that Tom read daily.
On the 12th day, Tom's resource room teacher introduced comic strip conversations. She spent approximately 15 minutes per day interpreting a social situation in a comic strip that Tom identified as problematic. Two samples of cartoons that Tom's resource center teacher drew to illustrate the social problems Tom experienced are included here. The first provides an example of a comic strip conversation that Tom's teacher used with him. This particular incident occurred when a girl told Tom that he had a "cute butt." The girl was attempting to tell Tom that she liked him. Tom, however, perceived the girl's comments as sexual harassment and replied in kind by calling the girl a sexist pig (see Figure 1).
The second shows Tom's attempt to talk to a friend by providing a compliment. Tom did not understand that the word he used ("preppy") held a negative connotation for his peers. His peer responded in a negative way; Tom offered a similar retort.
To determine whether the social stories and comic strip conversations were effective for Tom, his resource center teacher counted the number of verbal redirections that Tom needed to get to PE class, as well as the number of minutes he was late to class. Table 2 briefly describes her findings.
Research is needed to validate whether and under which circumstances social stories and comic strip conversations are effective. These two interpretive techniques appear to hold promise for children and youth with AS. They directly address an area of challenge seen in persons with AS--interpreting social situations that are primarily verbal and that offer little reflection time. Both techniques are also potentially important because they are adult- and student-friendly and are designed to be used in the classroom, home, and community settings with no need for expensive tools or specially constructed environments.
Table 1: Teacher-Created Social Stories to Help Tom Transition From Lunch to Physical Education Class
Social Story 2
Reflection Exercise #7