Questions? 800.667.7745; Voice Mail: 925-391-0363
Email: [email protected]
Add To Cart

Ethically Treating PTSD Resulting from Terroism and other Traumas

Section 1
Track #1 - Using Counterphobic Mechanisms to Reduce Stress

Question 1 | Answer Booklet | Table of Contents | Printable Page | Introduction

Read content below or listen to audio.
Left click audio track to Listen; Right click to "Save..." mp3

New Content Added: To update the content we have added PTSD information found at the end of the Table of Contents.

The Meaning of Stress

Walton T. Roth
First, let us look at victims of terrorism and factors that determine the stress of the experience for them. Walton Roth’s ideas underline the ethical need for individualization of the client as a unique person. After a terrorist siege has ended, physicians may describe the bodily damage in terms of physical injuries, but, as you know, in addition to any direct injuries, each participant in a terrorist incident has been exposed to a situation in which many subtle changes may have taken place in response to the stressor. We’ll look at these stressors in terms of four losses: loss of invulnerability, loss of an orderly world, loss of self-image, and loss of trust. As I am outlining these ideas, you might think about how they apply to clients you treated immediately following the September 11th Twin Towers attack.

Treating the Loss of Invulnerability:
A client, whom a colleague treated, had an uncle shot in a local mosque immediately following the September 11th attacks. The client stated, “This couldn’t happen to me. This couldn’t happen to my uncle,” she thought. Her next thoughts were, “But it did happen to you and your uncle, therefore you no longer feel the world is a safe place.” She stated, “I feel less safe than I did before his shooting. Even when others assure me that it can’t happen again, I know that it could and fear that it will.”

2 Symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

As you know, these feelings of vulnerability indicate two symptoms of PTSD, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder:
1. A sense of doom or an expectation of a foreshortened future, and
2. An intense fear that the trauma will repeat itself.
Thus, the ethical need for individualization to the client as a unique person is called for here, especially related to the client’s use of psychological defense mechanisms.

Hijacked Planes
In the case of the hijacked planes that crashed, the passengers were, of course, taken hostage. In the case of a hostage, the hostage’s first response might be, “I don’t believe this” or “This can’t be happening to me.” Loss of invulnerability is initiated. According to Ochburger the individual unconsciously and automatically refuses to comprehend the situation. For brief periods, denial helps. It permits time to lapse and protects the individual from physical collapse. Panic reactions are forestalled or made less likely. The temporary effects of denial give the victim an opportunity to gradually assess the situation and perhaps formulate coping strategies.

Counterphobic Mechanism
The individual who utilizes this counterphobic mechanism reduces stress and anxiety which may cause excessive and sometimes rash responses that actually oppose his basic inclinations for safety in a threatening situation. A simple example would be the case of a man with a fear of heights who insists on peering over the edge of a cliff. Counterphobic psychological defenses may serve the individual well in some stress situations, but in violent circumstances such as a hijacking incident, counterphobic behavior in these situations is sometimes termed bravery. But, as you know, this bravery can increase the chances that the victim will be injured or killed.

Reaction Formation
Closely related to the counterphobic mechanisms are those that are usually described as reaction formation and identification with the aggressor. However, these usually occur over longer periods of time and, thus, involve later phases of hostage situations. Reaction formation may be described as an adaptive process in which an individual adopts attitudes and behaviors that are, in fact, opposite to the impulses he harbors, either consciously or unconsciously.

For example, fear of the terrorist is transformed into approval or admiration. In a situation where one person is victimized by another, this process may extend to identification with the aggressor. When observed in the victims of terrorists, the process may be described in different terms, such as “identification with the captor,” or “identification with the controller.”

The victim unconsciously incorporates... the characteristics of the feared person and becomes psychologically allied with him. Thus, the victim transformed himself or herself from the person threatened into the person who makes the threat; thus, the victim reduces his anxiety. Should the victim seek therapy, an ethical issue may arise if the therapist finds himself or herself being judgmental regarding the victim’s attitude of identification with his or her captors.

QUESTION 1: What behaviors are closely related to the counterphobic mechanisms? To select and enter your answer go to Answer Booklet.

Answer Booklet for this course
Forward to Audio Track 2
Table of Contents

Email yourself a link to this page and start a "Professional Reference Folder of Interventions" for your future use. Or email a link to this page to Mental Health Professionals. No further emails will be sent to them.
* Required Field

Thanks ahead of time... for paying us the compliment of sharing our information with others! We strive to provide practical quality information and interventions in an affordable and easy to use format.

Email a link to this page, to yourself and start a "Professional Reference Folder of Interventions."
( This symbol indicates a key tool or idea.) Or email a link of this page to colleagues. No further emails will be sent to them.
If you have a Facebook page, log-in and share this page with your colleagues. The section name, link, and a brief description of this page will appear on your wall and your colleague’s News Feed.
If you have a Facebook page, log-in. Click the "Like" link. Then when we post Intervention Tools and Techniques to our MentalHealthCE Facebook page, ideas will be posted to your Facebook News Feed.